There are no "natural kinds of basic behavioural
units of culture equivalent to genes, cells, and organisms.
Therefore each major discipline- anthropology, sociology, political
science, and so forth- has been required to develop its own
conceptual base and language. ("nomic isolation." )
The discovery of natural units in culture would
represent a key advance in the social sciences. Most appear to
believe that such units either do not exist or, if they do exist,
cannot be derived by any means currently available.
However, there is some reason to believe that
natural units do exist and are built on the natural units of
semantic memory.
Semantic memory comprises words and symbolic
manipulation.
Episodic memory entails running through sequences
of visual and other sensory experience. It tends to organize
impressions into discrete clusters. Experimental studies have
revealed that mental cuts are made around objects or abstractions
that have the most attributes in common. Hence although categories
such as "tree," "dog," and "house" are collections of objects that
share a relatively large number of stimuli most easily processed by
the brain.
Children move easily into the semantic mode of
memory formation, performing equally well on objects or collections
of objects. They organize certain identifying stimuli into sets
(such as "cookies" versus "cakes" and "chairs" versus "stools")
that are almost as sharply demarcated as the separate objects
themselves.
The brain process these sets further by
compounding the clusters hierarchically into larger assemblages
that possess a discrete, interchangeable form.
The units of semantic memory, which are
experienced as obects or abstractions, are appropriately called
nodes.
There are at least three levels of nodes.
- Concepts, the most elementary clusters, are expressed by words
or phrases (such as "dogs" and "hunt").
- Propositions are signalled by phrases, clauses, or sentences
expressing objects and relationships ("dogs hunt").
- Schemata are signalled by sentences and larger units of text
(the "technique of hunting with dogs").
Node-link structures steadily enlarge in size and
complexity in the growing child, and the main steps in the growth
correspond at least roughly to the stages of mental development.
The stages are not mere accidents of personal growth but general
processes that show some regularity across cultures.
It is important for the relation of biology to
culture that the semantic mechanisms of culture formation are more
robust and consistent than the final products they generate. For
each concept the brain tends to select a prototype that constitutes
the standard, such as a particular wavelength and intensity to form
the idealized colour red or a particular body shape and size to
form the typical "dog."
Given an array of similar variants, the mind can
deduce a standard near the average of the variants and use it as
the prototype even without having perceived any example of it
directly. The most important result for gene-culture coevolution is
that the divisions are created and labelled, even when the stimuli
being processed vary continuously.
In short, the mind automatically imposes a
semidiscrete, hierarchical order upon the world.
Most of the concepts that make up the basic units
of semantic memory are arbitrary and arise from the particularities
of cultural history. Nevertheless there is a tendency for those
belonging to at least a few categories to occur consistently across
cultures.
Such categories include elementary geometric
forms (square, circle, equilateral triangle), the facial
expressions of six basic emotions (happiness, sadness, anger, fear,
surprise, disgust), and the basic colors (red, yellow, green,
blue).
The level of the node of semantic memory, whether
concept (the most elementary recognizable unit), proposition, or
schema, determines the complexity of the generated behaviour or
artifact maintained in the culture.
For example, the differentiation of letters or
ideographs is at the level of the concept, the initial verbal
reaction to a stranger is a proposition, and the expression of an
incest taboo is a schema.
If this model of semantic memory holds, new
discoveries refining the hierarchy of memory nodes can be expected
to advance the identification of culture units, or "culturgens," in
the same manner that advances in cellular chemistry have improved
our comprehension of the gene and studies of population structure
have refined our understanding of biological species.
Although a direct correspondence between nodes
and generative units of culture appears feasible at lower levels of
organization, there is no reason to expect the more complex
constructions of culture to be mapped onto semantic nodes in a
one-to-one fashion. Marriage ceremonies and temple architecture,
for example, are the outcomes of numerous interlocking behaviours
that result from cognitive activity with multiple culturgens. These
in turn vary according to the particularities of local history.
Nevertheless, each can be realistically interpreted as the outcome
of cognitive development, which is attained principally through the
assembly of node-link networks.